When Shohei Ohtani stepped back onto the mound June 16, he wasn’t just returning from injury. He was attempting something that defies baseball logic: being elite at both hitting and pitching in an era where specialization rules. After two elbow surgeries and two years away from pitching, the Los Angeles Dodgers superstar faced questions about whether his body could handle the dual workload that made him baseball’s most unique talent.
How Did Shohei Ohtani’s Second Elbow Surgery Change His Approach?
Ohtani’s journey back to the mound began with a 2023 surgery on his right elbow, the same arm that required Tommy John surgery during his 2018 rookie season. Speaking on “The Pat McAfee Show,” Ohtani revealed how different this recovery felt compared to his first major arm surgery.
“I actually felt pretty comfortable and better after the second surgery. Just the way the ball felt in my hands when I first threw. The progression throughout felt really comfortable,” Ohtani explained.
The 31-year-old’s confidence in his recovery process stands in stark contrast to the typical uncertainty that surrounds pitchers returning from elbow surgery. His comfort level suggests the surgical procedure and rehabilitation addressed the underlying issues that had kept him off the mound for two seasons.
However, Ohtani acknowledged the challenge ahead when asked about extending his outings beyond a couple of innings. “I really have to increase volume. Aside from that, I feel pretty good with what I have.”
What Do Ohtani’s Early Pitching Results Tell Us About His Readiness?
Through five starts since his June 16 return, Ohtani has posted numbers that suggest he’s ready for a larger workload. His 1.00 earned run average across nine innings, combined with 10 strikeouts and just two walks, demonstrates the command and stuff that made him one of baseball’s premier two-way players.
These statistics indicate Ohtani is ready to go deeper in a ball game, but they also raise questions about workload management. The sample size remains small, and the Dodgers must balance their immediate needs with Ohtani’s long-term health.
Meanwhile, Ohtani’s offensive production continues at an elite level. His 91 runs scored by the All-Star break, 32 home runs, and .988 OPS demonstrate he remains one of baseball’s most dangerous hitters. The combination of his pitching return and continued offensive dominance creates both opportunity and risk for the Dodgers.
Should the Dodgers Risk Ohtani’s Future for Present Success?
The Dodgers’ dilemma reflects a broader question about player management in modern baseball. Ohtani has undergone major arm surgeries in just six seasons of pitching, yet his desire to contribute on the mound remains strong. The front office, known for spending heavily to fill roster holes, faces a unique situation with a player whose skills cannot be replicated.
The long-term implications of increased pitching volume weigh heavily on organizational decision-making. While Ohtani wants to pitch more, the Dodgers must consider whether satisfying that desire serves their championship aspirations or puts their most valuable asset at unnecessary risk.
As World Series favorites, the Dodgers face the challenge of managing a player who defies conventional wisdom. Ohtani’s ability to impact games both at the plate and on the mound makes him irreplaceable, but his injury history serves as a reminder of the physical toll such versatility demands. The decision to trust their best player or protect him from himself will define both Ohtani’s career trajectory and the franchise’s championship window.
