Tennis fans erupted in criticism of the Cincinnati Open organizers after the men’s singles final between Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner ended prematurely due to the extreme afternoon heat.
The highly anticipated clash wrapped up in just 23 minutes on Monday, August 18, when Sinner, struggling with illness, was forced to retire while trailing 0-5 in the opening set. Many viewers argued that the tournament’s scheduling decision to stage the match at 3 p.m., the hottest part of the day, played a direct role in the disappointing outcome.
How Much Did Heat Play a Role in Jannik Sinner’s Retirement Against Carlos Alcaraz?
The abrupt finish capped off what had already been one of the most grueling weeks in Cincinnati in recent memory. Temperatures climbed as high as 88 degrees Fahrenheit, with oppressive humidity making conditions difficult for both athletes and fans. The brutal heat had been a recurring storyline throughout the tournament.
Felix Auger-Aliassime compared the atmosphere to “an oven,” while Daniil Medvedev was seen plunging his head into an ice cooler between games. Arthur Rinderknech collapsed during his third-round match against Auger-Aliassime, and Elena Rybakina, Alcaraz, and Sinner were repeatedly spotted applying ice towels to their necks in a desperate attempt to cool down.
In the final, Sinner looked visibly unwell. He apologized to the umpire and fans, tears welling up as he explained he “felt really bad” for those who had come to watch.
He shared an embrace with Alcaraz before walking to the middle of the court to raise his arms in apology, then returned to his seat and hid his face in a towel. Alcaraz, who was awarded his first Cincinnati title and eighth Masters 1000 trophy, consoled his opponent in a heartfelt moment.
So very sad to see @carlosalcaraz comforts a disappointed Jannik Sinner after the World No. 1 is forced to retire due to illness.@CincyTennis | #CincyTennis pic.twitter.com/RzCZJGVPUT
— ATP Tour (@atptour) August 18, 2025
The backlash surfaced immediately on social media after the official Cincinnati Open account posted a photo of Alcaraz consoling Sinner with the caption: “Feel better soon, Jannik. Congratulations to Carlos, our new champion.”
Feel better soon, Jannik.
Congratulations to Carlos, our new champion. pic.twitter.com/FAlgT8YUud
— Cincinnati Open (@CincyTennis) August 18, 2025
Replies flooded in with criticism directed at the tournament. One user wrote, “I think @atptour need to look at their schedule. There are way too many tournaments, which the players feel they need to play. So many players were clearly suffering in the Cincinnati heat and yet they still got a time violation. It’s madness.”
I think @atptour need to look at their schedule. There are way too many tournaments, which the players feel they need to play. So many players were clearly suffering in the Cincinnati heat and yet they still got a time violation. It’s madness
— billie laing (@billielaing1) August 18, 2025
Another posted, “Something has to change in the Cincinnati tournament organization. A final at 3pm in August with such a heat is unbearable.”
Something has to change in the Cincinnati tournament organization. A final at 3pm in August with such a heat is unbearable.
— Pascale Dillemann (@d_pascale) August 18, 2025
Others echoed similar frustrations, with one noting, “feel better? you made him play every match at 3pm! 36°C today!! Alcaraz is champion after 2 retirement.”
feel better? you made him play every match at 3pm! 36°C today!! Alcaraz is champion after 2 retirement.
— L @ U (@_laura_1889) August 18, 2025
Fans voiced disappointment over ticket prices for a final that lasted less than half an hour, with one remarking, “What the HELL are the organizers doing? Why schedule this match in the heat of the day? The women should of started at 6pm and the men at night at 8pm under the lights. Good grief. If I had to pay thousands for a final ticket to watch only 22 minutes, I would be pissed off.”
Were Organizers to Blame for the Disappointing Outcome?
Another fan pointed to the toll the weather had already taken on players throughout the week, writing, “players have been suffering from heat all throughout the tournament, some literally needing their heart rate checked and others fully retiring due to exhaustion. if this isn’t an indicator that SOMETHING needs to be changed about the schedule, i don’t know what is.”
Even those who questioned whether Sinner’s illness was directly tied to the temperature felt the scheduling was reckless. “i really don’t understand why they scheduled the final for the hottest time of the day. even if it wasn’t heat related with jannik, it definitely didn’t help that it was so warm,” one user commented.
MORE: Carlos Alcaraz Admits to ‘Struggling a Lot’ in Extreme Cincinnati Weather As He Reveals Tactics Against Opponents
Another went a step further, criticizing the financial motives behind the decision: “It’s time yall take sum accountability too..the whole week players be falling like trees, MTO’s more rampant than ever and yet y’all forced your way out to make them play like that…. Not taking anything away from Carlos but was the 200 Million worth it like that??”
Sinner’s withdrawal has put his 2025 US Open title defense in doubt. He is also entered in mixed doubles with Katerina Siniakova, but his participation in New York remains uncertain.
