The NASCAR playoffs have been a lightning rod all through the 2024-25 campaign, and the debate has only gotten louder as more fans speak out against the format. While Mark Martin helped amplify the anti-playoffs push earlier this year, a new spark hit the conversation when Michael Waltrip publicly backed the system on X, which drew a fast and fierce response.
What Did Michael Waltrip Say About the NASCAR Playoffs?
In a recent post on X, Michael Waltrip compared NASCAR to other major sports and argued that every sport has a playoff, using that as support for NASCAR’s approach. He posted, “Every sport has a playoff. Seems like a good idea. @NASCAR,” which quickly spread and kicked off a fresh round of debate.
Every sport has a playoff. Seems like a good idea. @NASCAR
— Michael Waltrip (@MW55) September 25, 2025
Shortly after his post went viral, the Notes feature on X flagged the first part of his statement and pointed out that most major motorsports like F1, IndyCar, and IMSA use full-season points rather than playoffs. While Waltrip may have been speaking broadly about sports, many fans took it as a direct comparison to motorsports and pushed back hard.
How Did Fans Respond to Waltrip’s Take?
Fans jumped in quickly, citing series that crown champions without playoffs and questioning the logic behind Waltrip’s comparison. One reply listed multiple leagues and motorsport series and even wondered whether a network pushed the take, asking, “Does Formula 1? Does The English Premier League? League 1? La Liga? Indy Car? IMSA? NBC slipping you money under the table for this take?”
Does Formula 1? Does The English Premier League? League 1? La Liga? Indy Car? IMSA? NBC slipping you money under the table for this take?
— Seth (@Seth_Cole33) September 25, 2025
Motorsports journalist Toby Christie also weighed in, keeping it simple while arguing against the playoff concept in stock car racing. He wrote, “Nothing but respect, Michael. But… NASCAR, everything else is just a game. No Playoffs needed here.”
Nothing but respect, Michael. But… NASCAR, everything else is just a game. No Playoffs needed here.
— Toby Christie (@Toby_Christie) September 26, 2025
Another fan questioned how Waltrip, coming from what they called the golden era, could support a format they believe changed how championships feel. The reply said, “How can you come from the golden era of NASCAR and advocate this when the playoffs have hurt the sport tremendously, and the champions don’t feel special anymore. Stop trying to hurt NASCAR.”
How can you come from the golden era of NASCAR and advocate this bullshit when the playoffs have hurt the sport tremendously and the champions don’t feel special anymore. Stop trying to hurt NASCAR
— Justin Champagne (@ChampagneRacin) September 26, 2025
Series like F1, IndyCar, and IMSA determine champions through a season-long points system that rewards higher finishing positions race to race. While each series uses its own scoring structure and incentives, none of these championships rely on a playoff model to pick the title winner.
ALSO READ: ‘The Issues Run Deeper’ — Insider Lays Out The Brutal Truth Behind NASCAR TV Ratings Collapse
Drivers in those series need to stack consistent results across the calendar to stay in contention, which keeps the focus on the full body of work rather than a late-season reset. That setup is central to why many motorsports fans prefer a traditional points race over an elimination-style playoff.
As the conversation rolls on, Waltrip has not responded to the pushback, and the reaction shows how divided the fanbase remains on the NASCAR playoffs. For now, the post lit up the discourse again and made it clear that many fans still want a different path.
